Getting to grips with theory: Transactional analysis

I honestly don’t know why but I’m a huge fan of ideas and theories that emerged in the late 50’s and 60’s. It was certainly a time when ideas about the importance of ‘self’ took hold with people like Rogers and Maslow exploring how to be our best selves – scaling the dizzy heights of self-actualisation! One such idea to come out of that same era was Transactional Analysis which is a way of examining the interactions between people.

It was developed by Eric Berne (1910-70) in the late 1950’s as a basis for understanding behavior through communication. Its origins are in groupwork where the transactions – the communication interactions – were analysed to develop understanding. It draws on a range of theoretical perspectives and considers ideas about the subconscious mind and its influence, so, is psychoanalytical. It is humanist in that sees the individual as important, and cognitive as it considers cognitive processes and seeks when necessary to attempt to adapt cognitive processes.

It can be used to explore the Individual, two person relationships and group interaction. Let’s explore its components.

Using Transactional Analysis in the Workplace - ReadyToManageStrokes

‘Strokes’ is a motivational concept where a ‘stroke’ is an act of recognition from one person to another. The communication of acceptance or ‘liking’, is referred to as positive stroking, whereas criticism and ‘discounting’ are negative stroking. There are parallels here with the concept of reinforcing in behaviorism and also ideas of affirmation and validation

Positive strokes would be things like praise, compliments, recognition, affection, rewards, sympathy, consolation, and even self-satisfaction from a job well done. Negative strokes would be put downs, criticism, ridicule, scolding, or punishment. Strokes can be ‘Conditional’ that is they relate to what you do and are not directly about you as a person – ‘you did  that task very  well’. Whereas unconditional strokes are not about what you do but are about you – ‘I really like you’. There is no condition just a statement.

Strokes can have ulterior motives where people say things to gain favor. I remember one student I taught used to say things like, ‘You’re looking good today Stephen – lovely shirt’, usually around assignment marking time!

Life positions - I'm okay, you're okay - GP-Training.netOk-ness

This idea refers to a basic attitude of acceptance towards self and others and states that people adopt one of four positions.

  • I’m Ok – You’re not Ok – this is rejection and belittling of the other. Maybe it’s ‘I don’t like you’ or ‘I don’t like what you represent’. It could be because the other person is constructively challenging and the person doesn’t like being challenged.
  • I’m Ok – You’re Ok – the preferred position – acceptance of self and others. This is the state we need to try and establish when working with people. Such a position can generate forward momentum.
  • I’m not Ok – You’re Ok – reflects avoidance of the other and maybe suggests things to be explored with the person. At least if the person thinks ‘you’re ok’ then this may give you a starting position as they may trust what you are saying.
  • I’m not Ok – You’re not Ok – Berne suggests reflects a depressive hopeless attitude to life. The question is how to create forward momentum and change in such a position.
A history of Eric Berne
Eric Berne

Ego states

Berne suggest there are three ego states – the parent, the adult, and the child. We can all, whether we are adults, parents or children adopt these ego states.

The Parent Ego state is when we adopt behaviours, thoughts and feelings copied from parents or parent figures so is a ‘taught’ ego state. The Adult Ego state is found in behaviours, thoughts and feelings which are a direct response to the here and now and are a ‘thought’ ego state. The Child Ego state is where we replay behaviours, thoughts, and feelings from childhood and is a ‘felt’ state.

Parent (“exteropsyche”): is a state in which people behave, feel, and think in response to an unconscious mimicking of how their parents (or other parental figures) acted, or how they interpreted their parent’s actions. For example, a person may shout at someone out of frustration because they witnessed that as a response, a way of being, in a parent or important person.

Adult (“neopsyche”): a state of the ego, which is very pragmatic and practical, thinking things through logically to make predictions and maybe absent of major emotions that could affect success. Learning to strengthen the Adult is a goal of Transactional Analysis. While a person is in the Adult ego state, they are directed towards an objective appraisal of reality. This resonates so much with me in terms of my writing about productivity and being organised. Developing this ego state means we can relate to people and events in a structured way. Not lacking emotions necessarily but being in control of them.

Child (“archaeopsyche”): a state in which people behave, feel and think similarly to how they did in childhood. The Child is the source of emotions, creation, recreation, spontaneity and intimacy. We need to spend some time in this state I’d argue but it needs to be carefully managed.

Transactions that are complimentary sustain and lead to smooth conversation

So, Adult to Adult could result in solving a problem, whereas Parent to Parent could lead to critical gossip (something lots of people enjoy! We are only human!). Child to Child or Parent to Child could be about playing together.

Banning Small Talk From Your Conversations Makes You Happier, Says Science  (Ask Any of These 12 Questions for a Change) | Inc.com

Crossed transactions cause communication to be broken and give us what is sometimes referred to as ‘a bumpy conversation ride’. Where the stimulus in the conversation originates in Adult and is directed to Adult but the respondent returns conversation from say Child directing it to Parent, or equally, Parent to Child, we may see a problem. I’m wanting to have a serious productive conversation, but I get a petulant child response, or a critical parent response and I’m left on the back foot not knowing quite what happened. Or indeed I’m after a bit of jovial childlike banter and I make a joke that falls flat on its face when someone responds from Adult and I’m left deflated. This happens a lot with my jokes…I need to think about that…. 😉

Within each of these ego states are subdivisions. Parental figures are often either more nurturing or more criticising. Childhood behaviours are either more natural (free) or more adapted to others. These subdivisions categorise individuals’ patterns of behaviour, feelings, and ways of thinking, that can be functional, beneficial, and positive, or dysfunctional, counterproductive, and negative.

Critical Parent can be lecturing or judging – all about what you should do or shouldn’t do. Remember this is not just ‘real’ parent to ‘real’ child – you can be ‘in’ Critical Parent in adult conversations. ‘I don’t know what you do with your time. I need the report now!’

Nurturing Parent on the other hand is sympathetic, advising, and takes care. ‘You seem to be missing deadlines can we talk about what we can maybe do to help?’

In the same problem above Adult may be objective, rational, and problem solving. ‘Let’s reach an agreement on giving you a little longer but it must be done by then. Let’s see what work we can take off you to give you time’.

The Adapted Child may then play the game (Berne loves game playing ideas) and may manipulate the situation trying to drive Adult into Nurturing Parent. ‘I’ve just found everything so hard lately’. Or maybe will be submissive and conform to Adult expectations. ‘Yes, whatever you want me to do’.

The Natural Child might be playful or impulsive and may rebel. ‘Sorry but I can’t I’m taking today off – nobody bothers about the dates things are due anyway!’

Strengths-based conversations: quick tips for practiceHow is this relevant to SW?

  • It helps us understand the other person
  • It gives us opportunity to consider how to respond in a helpful way to build rapport.
  • It helps communication by trying to shift the other persons ego state to Adult to establish an Adult to Adult conversation.
  • TA tells us you can have considerable impact on modifying behaviour by how you communicate. The Adult ego state seeks to ‘control’ the other ego states.

Using TA for effective communication

For effective communication you need to keep the transaction complementary i.e. focus on sender to receiver and receiver to sender where the message is sent to the ego state from which you expect a reply. Using ego states we can look at how others communicate and how we communicate with others.  It’s possible to identify which ego state we are in and which ego state we are expecting a reply from.

We can also use TA to help us plan transactions. For example, we can identify which ego state would be most valuable for us to send the message from and which ego state it would be better for it to be received by. If we receive a reply from the wrong (non expected) ego state then we can either try to shift the other person’s ego state or if we cannot do this it may be better to stop the communication and try again another time when the person may be in a different ego state.

We can listen to people’s communication to identify if they are habitually in one ego state and then decide if communication to that ego state would be appropriate or not. TA therefore can be used to elicit the reactions you want from other people (and this will happen consciously or unconsciously).  We are trying to achieve Adult to Adult

We can help communication if we need to by trying to shift the other person’s ego state by inviting people to move into a different ego state. They may not always move into it though, particularly if someone is habitually in one ego state. Do this by acknowledging their current ego state (by the appropriate message or response) and then invite them into another ego state by the words (and body language) which you use.

Transactional Analysis implies that you can have considerable impact by the way you communicate with others.

You can use your Adult ego state to think about what behaviour is appropriate and then engage in that way to facilitate helpful conversations. 

Solution Focused Gorillas

In 2006 Cadburys poisoned 37 people with Salmonella and the treasured British company was brought to it knees. Fined millions, reputation in the trash, hostile take over talk, how could it ever recover…………….

Cadbury’s response was marketing genius they ran one of the most famous adverts of the past twenty years.

[You really should watch it (below) –  it’s amazing! It’s 4 and half minutes long (this link is a shorter version – but if you have the time watch the long one – it is sooooo worth it!]


The advert features no humans (Phil Collins excepted) and no chocolate, it just creates a warm positive enjoyable feeling exactly the feeling that Cadburys wants associated to their brand.

By honing down to base psychology Cadburys have distanced themselves from their Salmonella existential crisis.  The advert was entirely positive, feel good and very importantly simple. Cadburys chocolate will make you feel like the advert does.

The next video….. well…. watch it then I’ll tell you….


It features the very same gorilla as in the Cadbury advert (honest!) in the now famous experiment by Simon and Chabris (2009). In the experiment the focus of the viewer is requested to be entirely on the white team passing the ball, the human brain squarely focuses on its target to the deletion of everything else.

Nearly all test subjects fail to spot the gorilla but can count accurately the number of passes of the ball, as soon as you are told of the gorilla it is 100% obvious, as gorillas always are.

Before the gorilla starred in adverts and experiments, he used to live in the jungle where he met famous primatologist (monkey expert) Diane Fosse.

The male gorilla before Fosse (and others Sigourney Weaver etc) had always been considered to be totally dominant in sexual situations with the female subservient and vulnerable.

As Matthew Syed points out in his excellent Rebel Ideas (2019) however, primatology was full of stuffy bearded men in the Charles Darwin mould who had a massive blind spot about female activity. They accepted the dominant view and importantly had no interest in challenging it creating a jaundiced perceived wisdom. Syed observes that it was not until a critical mass of female scientists entered the field that the frame of reference shifted and female gorillas were found to have agency and power, and, could select a range of sexual partners.

The story of this gorilla I feel is useful to solution focused work as it makes clear a very important point.

“You see what you aim at”

This quote by, at times controversial, psychologist Jordan Peterson I feel holds a lot of weight for social care. The power, and indeed ‘blindness’, that can be achieved by a clear focus is both useful and dangerous.

Here are some examples –

The social worker whose main focus is the assessment rather than supporting lasting and client led change, or the family whose only focus is to seek the end to the intervention never questioning or considering possible future directions or opportunities.

Conversely the focus on one particular issue for a period of time can yield results as nobody can deal with many problems all at the same time (I’m sure many of us have all been to child protection or adult safeguarding meetings where the list of identified issues is long).

To balance this I feel as social workers we need a wide lens to be open to risky ideas that will reverse challenging situations (Cadburys),  we must be brave not to fall under the cloak of perceived and dominant thinking (Dianne Fosse) and to be focused on the detail but not to miss the gorilla in the room (Simon and Chabris).

George Bull

George is a Social Worker at the Connected Carers Team South Tyneside. He has been a social worker for 10 years working mainly in child protection and Early Help. He has lectured with Jamie Scorer at New College Durham, University of Sunderland and University of Northumbria in solution focused practice.

References:

Simon and Chabris (2009) https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1068/p281059

Rebel Ideas, Syed (2019) https://www.amazon.co.uk/Rebel-Ideas-Power-Diverse-Thinking/dp/1473613914

Getting to grips with theory: Biology – deterministic?

Philosophers forever have contemplated just where the mind is and how the mind relates to both brain and body. Descartes, a French philosopher from the 17th century, was closely associated with an idea called dualism. This idea holds that the mind is non-physical – that it’s situated somewhere other than the brain or body. It’s not a substance – it’s in fact consciousness itself. He called this the mind-body problem. He said that mind can exist outside of the body and that the body cannot think. Mental phenomena are not physical. This gives birth the idea of soul – that there is a part of us that is not physical that exists beyond us

Rupert Sheldrake – a contemporary philosopher and man of faith says that our minds are part of a greater mind – that our minds exist outside of us and are part of something.

He used the analogy of a bucket of water reflecting the moon. The moon is clearly out there but it is also in a sense in the bucket. This is like our minds, he suggests. They are part of us – but they are also in other places. I don’t necessarily agree with this but it’s an interesting idea that has been with us for a long time.

With developments in neuroscience we can very much see that when the mind is active the brain is active. There is a contemporary argument that our mind is made up of nothing other than the physical brain, the chemicals, and the electrical impulses that take place.

Many think that as a consequence of new developments in neuroscience we can’t ignore the fact that many of our emotions and our responses are fuelled by chemical reactions in the brain. Think of nothing more than the fight or flight response that is driven by cortisol and adrenaline. When we’re stressed or scared, we become flooded with those chemicals and we respond to the presence of those chemicals by ‘fighting’ or ‘flighting’. This fuels a response in our sympathetic nervous system. We have another system called the parasympathetic nervous system which also has a little two-word analogy – the ‘rest and digest’ system or sometimes the ‘feed and breed’ system. Because when that system is activated we relax enough to take care of some of the other functions that our bodies needs to undertake in order to remain well. What we know is that if we are in a constant state of stress and if our sympathetic nervous system is dominant then our parasympathetic nervous system doesn’t get a look in. This, in many ways, is the ‘bio’ part of the biopsychosocial model.

I’d argue that as social workers we focus quite a bit on the social part of that model and to a significant extent on the psycho part of it, but we neglect the bio part. Emma Zara O’Brien in her book ‘Psychology, Human Growth and Development for Social Work’ (brilliant book – buy it!) says that the brain is arguably the foundation for, and core of, a person’s future development, behaviours, and experiences. She suggests that not being engaged with neuroscience or the biological underpinnings of human development reduces social workers ability to work alongside and with other professionals.

For many years it was believed that once we reached adulthood the brain was pretty much fixed. We know this now not to be true. The brain has a plasticity – an ability to change and develop. The brain reacts to changes in environment shaped by experience both positive and negative in children and in adults. Harari in his excellent book ‘Sapiens’ talks about this. He talks about our historic animal brain. I can relate this very much to how I see my dog ‘operate’. Essentially primitive brains work in two ways objectively and subjectively. So, my dog knows that if she runs into something it’s hard and it hurts. She knows that the world is full of smells and structures and she knows subjectively how she feels about them. She experiences excitement when she gets treats, she experiences fear if she doesn’t understand something, she experiences delight when having her tummy tickled. She understands the world in these simple objective and subjective ways. One of the problems for our human, developed, brain is that we have the capacity to move beyond objective and subjective understanding to know that there are things out there and feelings inside of us. But those feelings inside of us are still being driven by our primitive brain.

The amygdala the thing driving our fight or flight response is one of the oldest parts of our brain that we have and it’s not clever in the way it deals with things. It’s a one trick pony. It fuels us with adrenaline and cortisol. Humans have developed intellect and create stories about objective things and subjective experiences. We use everything we have to construct ideas of the world.

At birth our brain is 25% of its eventual adult weight. By a child’s second birthday the brain will have grown to 75% of its adult weight. This shows how much development of the brain is going on in the first 2 years of a child’s life as it explores its environment and experiences what’s going on around it. The change is rapid. The child is born with innate reflexes and as the brain develops the child develops ways to take control of these innate reflexes.

Our patterns of communicating are largely shaped by our early experiences from our primary caregivers. The brain needs a stimulating environment. If a child is severely neglected the brain does not develop normally. Sometimes pathways for language can be lost. The brains of children who’ve been denied stimulation can weigh less than the brains of children who have had such stimulation.

At around three years old the hippocampus matures, and this allows the retention of memories to begin – children have few memories before this time. Between the ages of 6 and 13 a growth spurt affects the brain regions concerned with language and spatial relationships. These changes improve thinking and social development and fuel abilities like being able to read, and social abilities like being able to make friends. Early experiences shape the people that we become.

Dr. Sunderland in the 2006 book The Signs of Parenting suggests the following. The developing brain in those crucial first years of childhood is highly vulnerable to stress. Many parenting techniques that are common can upset the delicate balance and stress response systems in the child. This can cause actual cell death in certain brain structures. Quality of life across the life course is dramatically affected by whether or not you established good stress regulating systems in your brain in childhood. One of the amygdala’s main functions is to work out the emotional meaning of everything that you experience. If the amygdala senses that something threatening is happening to you it communicates with another structure called the hypothalamus and this part of the brain actions the release of stress hormones which can prepare your body for fight or flight. Sunderland suggests that if you were left in childhood to manage your own painful feelings on your own your higher brain may not have developed the necessary wiring to be able to perform those wonderful stress managing functions. But all is not lost as the brain is malleable so talking therapies and other life experiences can mitigate against this. But, sadly, some people are left without this opportunity to transform.

The adult brain is fully mature at around 25 years of age. At this age and further into adulthood we have more thoughtful perceptions of the world around us (hopefully!) as the prefrontal cortex is fully developed and we can consider the consequences of our actions through reasoning. A lot of what I’m interested in in terms of self-care has implications here. Exercise promotes the development of brain derived neurotrophic factor. Brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), is a protein that stimulates the production of new brain cells and strengthens existing ones. When you release BDNF it helps grow brand new brain cells and pathways. High levels of BDNF makes you learn faster and remember better. BDNF also increases your brain’s plasticity – its ability to adapt. When you face stressful situations BDNF protects brain cells and helps them come back stronger. Exercise naturally raises levels of BDNF in your body. Cardiovascular exercise is best and, while a one-off session does no harm, BDNF increases more effectively with regular engagement in exercise. Your hippocampus, often referred to as the brake to your amygdala, shrinks as you get older and BDNF can maintain and even enlarge it.

When you rest (and meditate) you brains Default Mode Network is activated. This is a series of interconnected parts of the brain that get to work once we stop concentrating on external things – once we shift from outward focus to inward focused cognition. Interestingly people who rest effectively have more complex and better connected DMN’s. The complexity of our DMN shapes our capacity for self-awareness. Daniel Goleman says this leads to us being better pilots of our lives, helps us imagine our future, and gives us a greater ability to show empathy.

Our biology then has a significant impact on how, and maybe even ‘who’, we are. This begins to be shaped in our childhood and can continue to be shaped as adults. The impact is a direct consequence of environment, others, and self. We need to attend to all of these things for our personal wellbeing and, as social workers, need an awareness of these connections to help inform people of the potential for change and support people to facilitate such change to become those competent pilots of life.

Getting to grips with theory: Social Constructionism

In order to explore Social Constructionism, I feel we need to take a step back and we’ll do that by having a think about how we know what we know.

Let’s start with positivism. Positivism is a Philosophical position about knowledge – the how we know what we know bit. It’s a belief that it is possible to establish ‘objective truths’ – facts – about things. In social sciences it would be an attempt to apply the same approach as you would to the ‘natural sciences’ and some would argue that that is not possible or even helpful. Positivism would search for concrete causes and causal links.

But maybe it’s not that easy to do such a thing after all nature (things like physics or chemistry for example) is a set of ‘impersonal forces’ but society involves a mixture of forces (e.g. the political, or culture etc). The decisions and actions that people carry out they, in some ways, make for themselves. How human beings interpret a situation is crucial which means there’s no one answer because we all may interpret things differently. Social sciences therefore are concerned with meanings and reasons rather than causes. You might argue that Positivism looks for certainties that are not there.

This takes us to postmodernism. Postmodernism is a school of thought that rejects the notion of objective truths and natural laws and ‘grand theories’ for explaining human behaviour and the world. It is also critical of the idea that developments in science and technology will inevitably lead to improvement (modernism). This is an interesting thing to think of when you have a moment or several! Are we better off as a consequence of the modern world? Alvin Toffler in his 1970 book Futureshock says that we as a human animal are colliding with the incessant change we see and that we are simply not biologically ready for the modern world – needing to be always switched on and always ready to go! Postmodernists feel there is no absolute understanding of society or reality and our sense of reality is shaped through social interactions and processes.

And this leads us to Social Constructionism. Social Constructionism is critical of the positivist approach to knowledge – that everything is knowable as an absolute fact. Our historical and cultural context is important, and knowledge and reality are constructed in our daily interactions and conversations which in turn shapes our knowledge of ‘how to go on’. Different constructions are maintained by patterns of action – ‘practices’ – the way we conduct ourselves in situations for example. There is a construction of lecturer – you expect certain things from me when I’m being one. And there is a construction of student – I expect things from you when you are being one. And others have a view on what ‘student’ is. What if my view and your view and their view are all different? Because they might be. I think you’re a vessel to be filled with knowledge. You think you’re a customer who demands what you need to know to pass the assignment. And others…. Well they could construct you and I in all manner of ways… and they do!

Language describes and defines things and as such has power. Harari in his book Sapiens explains that as the human animal we are the same, as a starting point at least, as other animals. We look at things from a subjective and objective point of view. Objectively we know that things are hard – like if we walk into them – or things are wet – if they are poured over us. We also have a subjective point of view – I’m afraid of heights! It makes me feal fear – and I have a physical reaction to it – my legs turn to jelly.

Harari goes on to say though that unlike animals we tell ourselves stories about things that are imposed on top of these objective and subjective realities. We tell ourselves stories called our family, or our culture, or my job. We tell ourselves stories about what ‘parent’ means or what ‘school’ means, or what ‘student’ means. We have an idea for ourselves sometimes, but that idea is born out of stories we have been told by others – maybe by our cultural position, or through what we have read, or the media. So those stories both describe and define something that will have some similarities with others but will also be nuanced – slightly different – and in some cases, possibly across culture for example, very different. Wetherell and Maybin (in Stevens – Understanding the Self 1996 Sage London) says that this also extends to feelings – quoting Rosaldo (1984) ‘Feelings are not substances to be discovered in our blood, but social practices organized by stories that we both enact and tell”

In terms of this construction of self the person and social context merge because the boundaries of both can’t be easily separated from each other. Psychology, it could be argued, seeks to switch off the social context and the influence of others so that the picture of an individual’s psychological make up is not complicated by such things. Social constructionists say this is simply not doable.

Language is not just a way of describing something that already exists. Words do things as well as having meaning. Language is not a mirror reflecting the objects in our world, but a tool that constructs our world. This brings us to the idea of discourse. Discourse, as defined by Foucault, refers to ways of constituting knowledge that together with the social practices, forms of subjectivity, and power relations, form more than ways of thinking but actually produce meaning.

So, discourse is a systematic ordering of language involving certain rules, terminology and conventions, such as the legal or medical discourse – or indeed social work. Social work has a whole language of its own – Assessment, Care Plan, Safeguarding, Capacity – all things that have very specific meetings within social work discourse and may have other meanings elsewhere. It is a group of statements which provide a language for talking about a particular kind of knowledge about a topic.

Knowledge is flexible, not necessarily concrete, it moves and shifts. The particular ‘common sense’ view of the world prevailing in a culture at any point in time is bound up with power- these are referred to as normalising truths – we normalise or accept as given a particular truth or version of something. Think about the construction of gender or ethnicity over the last 200 years where certain versions were accepted or tolerated by many. This leads to social practices or ‘sites of practice’ that perpetuate that view of the world and marginalise alternatives. It gives us a particular way to look at things that may prove hard to shift because they create opportunities for power that can be used to maintain a position. Powerful ‘knowledges’ keep us in order and get us to control ourselves through the acceptance of the status quo.

So how we construct our reality, the things around us, is influenced by others like family, friends, and colleagues, and by things like media and government. These constructs have a power that is found in them and in the language that describes and defines them.

Social Constructionism recognises ‘the importance of a much more fluid and artistic form of knowledge’. It also suggests that there are complex uncertainties which fits with what we know in social work. How we construct things is fluid and needs to be constantly refined, explored, and challenged I’d argue. Social Constructionism suggests that practices should resist accepted and powerful forms of knowledge.

Social Work is not merely the exercise of ‘technical rationality’. Technical Rationality uses measurements, and empirical research, applies theory, uses instruments and frameworks to collect information, and works towards a ‘truth’ about individual needs. It helps the worker, in the role of expert, generate the ‘right’ answers.  As a contrast ‘Practice moral’ offers an interpretation of need based on values, empathy, and experience. It uses reasoning and accepts a variety of perceptions from within the service user’s life (Lishman 2014). It acknowledges that real world problems are ‘messy and indeterminate’ (Parton 2003 p2).

To develop understanding Service users and practitioners should emphasise the centrality of ‘talk’. This forges meanings and relationships. It underpins some key social work ideas like strengths-based approaches (seeing the world the way the service user does to draw on what they bring), and solution focused approaches which seek to achieve the same. A narrative approach helps social workers explore people lives through having them tell their story. The ideas of Social Constructionism suggest that engagement in conversations and interactions, and the patterns of practice these create offers the opportunity to generate new meanings – to become ‘poetic activists’ (Gergen, 1999 p.43 in Parton 2003)

Taking a such an approach from this theoretical position helps practitioners identify the significance of complexity, context, and process and considers where power is at play in those areas. It considers the notion of reflexivity – the ability to examine our own beliefs and practices and adjust them as we go. It emphasises and recognises a range of possibilities for understanding a situation and developing possible responses. It creates a collaborative approach to creating meanings.

There is a sense we are wanting to know ‘how’ rather than knowing ‘that’. We want to know how someone thinks about something rather than simply knowing that they simply think about it in a particular way – a search for meaning and its root, if you like. Such understanding is crucial so that we understand that people are constructing their own version of reality out of their experiences and that they are building and constructing their own world.

References

Burr, V. (2003) Social Constructionism 3rd Ed Sussex: Routledge
Gergen, K. (1999) An Invitation to Social Constructionism Sage

Parton, N. (2003 Rethinking Professional Practice: The contributions of Social Constructionism and the Feminist ‘Ethics of Care’ The British Journal of Social Work, Volume 33, Issue 1, 1 January 2003, Pages 1–16

Lishman, J., Yuill, C., Brannan, J. & Gibson, A. (2014 Social Work: An Introduction London: Sage (Paragraph on pg. 66 on Social Interactionism)

O’Brien, E.Z. (2020 Psychology, Human Growth and Development for Social Work (2nd ed.) London: Palgrave
Payne, M. (1997) Modern Social Work Theory London: Macmillan

Getting to grips with theory: Social Learning Theory

I can’t help but think of this poem when I think about Social Learning Theory because I think it says what it is perfectly…. From the immense poet Philip Larkin – This Be The Verse (That’s the name of the poem – I haven’t just turned into a pirate!!)

They fuck you up, your mum and dad.
They may not mean to, but they do.   
They fill you with the faults they had 
And add some extra, just for you.

But they were fucked up in their turn
By fools in old-style hats and coats,
Who half the time were soppy-stern
And half at one another’s throats.

Man hands on misery to man.
It deepens like a coastal shelf.
Get out as early as you can,
And don’t have any kids yourself.

Social Learning Theory is a Psychological theory despite the insistence of it having ‘social’ in the title just to confuse everyone! I’m sure you intuitively get how it works from the poem! You may well have picked up traits and ideas, and all manner of things from your parents, your family, your peers… the list goes on. You learn how to go on and what to do from others.

Usually when we talk about this theory, we think of negative things that we pick up from others possibly because the behaviour learnt in Bandura’s famous (and in my view highly dubious in terms of the ethics!) experiment was negative (more later). So, remember we can learn positive things as well! Role modelling… that’s what it is.

The theory is rooted in behaviorism. The fundamental idea of behaviourism is that behaviours that are reinforced will tend to continue, while behaviours that are punished will eventually end – referred to as conditioned responses. We develop learned responses to external stimuli – conditioning.

Social Learning Theory also draws on cognitive psychology because what is also important is what happens after stimulation but before reaction – the thinking bit – the flow of information in your mind before you decide what you are going to do. Our view of the world is self-constructed inside our minds so interpretation of what we observe is also at play. Our brains have a plasticity so although we do learn behaviours, we can modify them – so this is not a fatalistic position. You are not stuck with behaviour you learn but you might decide to stick with it even if it’s not good for you or you might stick with it because you don’t know any other way.

Albert Bandura was an American/Canadian Psychologist working in the early part of the 20th Century on observational learning theory. He observed that conditioning occurs not just from internalising behaviour we are exposed to but from our conscious observation of others.

He suggested that individuals that are observed are called models. These models provide examples of behaviour to observe and imitate so we figure out how to behave from what we see. If someone imitates a model’s behaviour and the consequences are rewarding, then they are likely to continue performing that behaviour. This is reinforcement and can be external or internal and can be positive or negative. For example, if a child wants approval from her parents and such approval is given and reinforces behaviour then such approval is an external reinforcement – it comes from outside herself. But if she is feeling happy about being approved of, and that reinforces her behaviour then that is an internal reinforcement.

If you want to know how Bandura discovered this then this video below will do the job! Save me telling you 😉

Context also plays a role. I suspect you can think of different ways you would act in different places and when with different people. You may well be different when eating out with your parents than you are when you eat out with the boys for a curry. We learn how to behave in different settings – if you want the fancy words around this it’s – cross-situational variability of behaviour. Children are great at it! Those of you who have children know they behave very differently at Grandma’s than they do at home because they know they get away with more and they behave differently at school because they know they get away with nothing – conniving little monkeys!

Bandura says there are four mediational processes at play in Social Learning Theory. These are mental processes that mediate between the stimulus and response. Individuals do not automatically observe the behaviour of a model and imitate it. There is some thought prior to imitation and this consideration is the mediational process. This occurs between observing the behaviour (stimulus) and imitating it or not (response)… so like I said earlier – the thinking bit.

The first is Attention. This is the extent to which we are exposed to, or notice, the behaviour. More exposure or more noticing could lead to more learning. Then Retention. This is how well the behaviour is remembered. Much learning in this way is not immediate. Even if the behaviour is reproduced shortly after seeing it, there needs to be a memory to refer to. We then get to Reproduction. This is the ability to perform the behaviour that the model has just demonstrated. And finally, Motivation – the will to perform the behaviour. Once the behaviour is initiated the rewards and punishment that follow will be considered by the observer. If the perceived rewards outweigh the perceived costs, then the behaviour will be reinforced and will be more likely to be imitated by the observer.

Social Learning Theory may help us understand that people learn behaviour from their immediate environment, not just their past, although it comes from there too. But all is not lost because the brain has a plasticity so behaviour can be modified. If people can learn ineffective ways of being, then they can acquire, through ‘learning’, other ways and so maintain and change behaviour. I feel that social work is one of few professions that always sees the potential of people to change no matter how difficult their circumstances or ingrained and deeply rooted their behaviour is – we need to hang onto that don’t you think?